Defence of Realm Regulations

According to the Gerry O’Neill’s Kilkenny GAA Bible (2014, pp. 60-61, available at http://www.kilkennygaa.ie/Downloads/KK_GAA_BIBLE_2014.pdf ) Glenmore between 1900 and 1950 won the Ned Langton Cup (county senior football championship) 15 times. Previously we posted information and a photo of the 1915 senior football team that won the County Kilkenny Senior Football Championship ( available at https://glenmore-history.com/the-tenacious-glenmore-1915-football-team-co-kilkenny-senior-football-champions/ ). Today, we will highlight some of the problems the 1916 Glenmore team faced before they again won the County Kilkenny Senior Football Championship. No senior football championships were held in County Kilkenny in 1917 and 1918 which was due to a number of factors primarily linked to the souring relationship between the Irish people and the British authorities.

Four final games were played between Glenmore and Coolagh for the 1915 football championship, the fourth and final game was not played until October 1916. It was not until December 1916 that Glenmore was declared the winners by the County Kilkenny Committee of the G.A.A. Also, in December it was announced that under the Defence of Realm Regulations, under a circular issued on the 18^th of November, excursion railway traffic in Ireland was to stop. The chief effect of this decision was that football and hurling matches would be adversely impacted. (Sport (Dublin), Sat. 2 Dec. 1916, p. 1). The rationale for this decision was alleged to be because of the scarcity of coal, yet the suspension of excursion trains did not extend to race meetings or coursing matches (New Ross Standard, Fri. 1 Dec. 1916, p. 2). As previously reported the use of automobiles was also restricted in 1917 (https://glenmore-history.com/the-prosecution-of-glenmore-wedding-guests-in-1917/).

In 1916 the U.K. Parliament sought to place a tax on the gate receipts under what was labelled the Amusement Tax. The G.A.A. prevailed upon John Redmond, M.P. who managed to insert into the proposed legislation exemptions for cultural events. In 1917, the Commissioners of Customs and Excise began taking cases again the G.A.A. for failing to pay the tax. The G.A.A. defended the cases asserting that the Gaelic games were exempt as it was engaged in the revival of national games. The Commissioners pointed out that they had not granted any exemptions and the courts became divided.

In January 1917, at the meeting of the Kilkenny County Committee of the G.A.A., long discussions took place regarding improperly constituted teams. The Chair announced that he would disqualify all improperly constituted teams from the championship. In the future there would be no refixing of matches except under special circumstances (Kilkenny Moderator, Sat. 13 Jan. 1917, p. 3). While Kilkenny was wrestling with the refixing of matches other aspects of legislation to support the war effort, such as mandatory food production, was impacting on G.A.A. grounds. For example, the owner of a large field at Carrickmacross announced that he had to plough the field under the imposed tillage scheme. A large crowd assembled at the field on the morning 40 ploughs were suppose to arrive to plough the ground, but none arrived (Belfast News Letter, Wed. 14 Feb. 1917, p. 6).

Notwithstanding its assertions that it was not a political organisation, in 1917 the G.A.A. began holding tournaments and exhibition matches to support the work of the Irish National Aid Association and the Volunteer Dependent’s Fund. After the Easter Uprising in 1916 financial support poured in from Irish exiles abroad, particularly those in the United States, for the dependents of the leaders of the rising who were executed. The Irish National Aid Association and the Volunteer Dependent’s Fund was established to raise and distribute the national and international relief. For documents relating to the organisation held by the National Library of Ireland see, Holdings: Irish National Aid Association and Volunteer… (nli.ie).

Notwithstanding the ban on the use of automobiles and excursion trains the G.A.A. continued to hold matches. Coolroe was to play Tullogher at the Rower but failed to travel for the first round of the 1916 senior football championship. The second time the match was cancelled due to snow. In March 1917 on the third attempt Coolroe again failed to travel and a walk over was awarded to Tullogher. (Enniscorthy Guardian, Sat. 17 March 1917, p. 6.) Apparently the awarding of the walk over was overturned by the County Committee and the two teams met on 13 May 1917. It was reported that the game was fast and well contested. The game score was Coolroe two points and Tullogher one point (New Ross Standard, Fri. 18 May 1917, p. 6).

While Glenmore was waiting for the Coolroe and Tullogher semi-final to be played a tournament was arranged at Mullinavat for the 19^th of April 1917 to aid the Irish National Aid Association. Glenmore played Tullogher “and a very fine game was witnessed,” by the large number of spectators. Glenmore won by 2 goals, 9 points to 1 point (New Ross Standard, Fri. 4 May 1917, p. 2) and Kilmacow played a drawn game with Chapelhill in the hurling encounter at that tournament (Munster Express, Sat. 5 May 1917, p. 5).

Shortly after that tournament both Tullogher and Glenmore became part of the “mania” sweeping the country. Republican flags were being placed in inaccessible places making their removal difficult without risk to life or limb. “On Sunday morning a Republican flag was floating on a staff from the eaves of the Tullogher National School. It remained there all day. On Sunday morning three Republican flags were seen floating near Glenmore. It is stated that two were on the tops of trees and another on the telegraph wires, and the police proceeded to remove them” (New Ross Standard, Fri. 18 May 1917, p. 3). In Tipperary after a match in July a Sinn Fein flag was displayed from the wagonette on which the Mullinahone footballers were seated, and one of the players attempted to address the crowd. When the police interfered “the crowd resented police interference, and a general melee ensued. The police charged the crowd with batons, and the people retaliated with stones.” The police withdrew to return with reinforcements, rifles and bayonets. “Some local traders and a clergyman persuaded the crowd to go home quietly.” Both police and members of the crowd received minor injuries (Kilkenny Moderator, Sat. 21 July 1917, p. 5).

From the newspapers it appears that Glenmore continued to play in the 1916 championship as well as the 1917 season. For example, the Glenmore v. Coolagh football tie was refixed for Knocktopher on Sunday 15^th July (Munster Express, Sat. 19 May 1917, p. 5) and the 1916 senior football championship match between Glenmore and Coolroe was to be held at Knocktopher on the 22^nd of July (Kilkenny Moderator, Sat. 14 July 1917, p. 3).

In the July meeting of the County Committee an objection was made by the Milebush junior hurling club regarding a match played at Glenmore on the 10^th of June which was awarded to Mooncoin. Milebush alleged two players for Mooncoin played senior hurling the previous year for other teams and Mooncoin countered that Milebush was illegally constituted as it included players affiliated and registered with the Glenmore hurling club. Mr. Heffernan responded “that there was no hurling club affiliated from Glenmore.” It was also reported that at a recent match at Glenmore in the second round of the junior hurling championship the Glenmore field had long grass which militated against the players displaying their skill (New Ross Standard, Fri. 20 July 1917, p.6).

A description of a senior football game played by Glenmore for the 1916 championship could not be located. However, although Coolroe appeared reluctant or unable to travel to matches Glenmore played in a number of fundraising tournaments to support the funding of the Irish National Aid Association. A tournament was arranged for the 9th of September 1917 at Knocktopher and Glenmore was pitted against Coolagh, the team it played four times to win the 1915 Senior Football Championship. The Knocktopher tournament “was patronized by a large gathering of Gaels, and it is satisfactory to note that a good ‘gate’ was realised. There was an attractive programme arranged, and those who attended … were treated to a first-class exhibition of” hurling and football. It is assumed that the following concerns the junior football team. “Glenmore and Kilmoganny were the first to enter the arena and, though the latter team failed to score, there were some masterly displays. Glenmore pressed throughout and the Kilmoganny defence was hard set to cope with the repeated assaults. Hanrahan, Freany, Fitzgerald, Hartley and Heffernan were about the best of the Glenmore boys who emerged victorious with a score of 3 goals, 3 points to nil. Mr. W. Saunders proved a capable referee. The Glenmore team…M. Cody, Capt; Jim Hanrahan, W. Purcell, J. Fitgerald, T. Freany, M. Cody, P. Reddy, J. Phelan, R. Walsh, J. Aylward, A. Heffernan, J. Cody, P. Hartley, R. Flynn and J. Phelan.

The event of the evening was the meeting of Glenmore and Coolagh for senior football honours. The pace was fast and the game was scarcely five minutes in progress when Jim Hanrahan scored the first point for Glenmore. Hanrahan was again conspicuous in the remaining stages of the first half, scoring a second point from a ‘free.’ The third and fourth minor scores quickly followed per Walsh and Doherty. Coolagh put up a stubborn fight but were unable to cope with the resistance of the Glenmore backs and centre players. When the half-time whistle sounded the score was: Glenmore—4 points; Coolagh—Nil.

Coolagh made repeated onslaughts when play was resumed, but were successfully held back by their opponents. Play continued fast and exciting, both sides showing much grit and determination. Though rough at times, the game was not remarkable for any foul passages of play. After some hard fought struggles to get through, Coolagh succeeded in penetrating a strong defence and their only score, a point was the result. Glenmore had luck on their side, but their play showed lack of style, their forwards losing several changes of scoring. The Coolagh backs proved strong and put up a good defence. The final scores were: Glenmore—4 points; Coolagh—1 point.

Jim Hanrahan, Jim Phelan, John Phelan, A. Heffernan and J. Doherty did good work as Glenmore representatives, while J. McKenna, M. Saunders, M and P Hoyne and J. Murphy were about the best of the Coolagh players. Mr. Dick Holohan, who gave every satisfaction as referee…The Glenmore team: J. Doherty (capt.), Jim Hanrahan, Jim Phelan, John Phelan, A. Heffernan, M. Connolly, J. Murphy, P. Foran, P. Forristal, P. Fitzgerald, C. McDonald, M. Murphy, J. Roche, W. Walsh, W. Hartley” (Munster Express, Sat. 22 Sept. 1917, p. 4).

At the October meeting of the Kilkenny County Committee the chairman, Mr. John Gibbons, in an attempt to stop the infighting on the Committee noted that when he took up the position of chair the affairs of the county committee had been in a state of chaos and dislocation. He thanked Mr. Aylward, of Mullinavat, for taking on the secretarial work and stepping into the breach.  The senior football final between Glenmore and Coolroe was fixed for New Ross on Sunday, 11^th November, with Mr. G. Kennedy to referee. (Kilkenny Moderator, Wed. 17 Oct. 1917, p. 2). It was later reported that the Kilkenny senior football championship at Barrett’s Park, New Ross would be played on the 18^th of November (Munster Express, Sat. 10 Nov. 1917, p. 5 & Waterford News & Star, Fri. 9 Nov. 1917, p. 5). The match did not occur because Coolroe notified Glenmore that they would not be able to travel (New Ross Standard, Fri 23 Nov. 1917, p. 6). The match was reset for the 6^th of January 1918 (Kilkenny Moderator, Wed. 12 Dec. 1917, p. 3) but the only reference that we could locate in local newspapers provided that the teams met on the 10^th of March 1918 for the second time at Barrett’s Park, New Ross to decide the final of the Co. Kilkenny senior football championship. The final score was reported as Glenmore, 3 goals, 2 points; to Coolroe, nil (Munster Express, Sat. 16 March 1918, p. 3). This score contradicts the score recorded by Gerry O’Neil for the 1916 final. It is also reported in his book that the 1917/1918 senior football championships were not held.

Given all the contradictions and confusion regarding the 1916 Kilkenny Senior Football Championship, with access limited to available newspaper accounts due to COVID 19 restrictions, any and all corrections would be very welcome.

There is no known photo of the 1916 Glenmore Team, but several of the players also played on the 1915 team. The featured photo above is courtesy of the National Archives. The identification of players in the photo is found with the blog post https://glenmore-history.com/the-tenacious-glenmore-1915-football-team-co-kilkenny-senior-football-champions/ .

Dr. Kathleen Moore Walsh